Getting a second opinion: when, how and what to bring

17 itemsChecked November 20, 2026
The short answer

It is normal to ask for a second opinion before a big surgery or treatment. Check what your plan covers (Medicare Part B covers second opinions for many non-emergency surgeries), send all your records ahead, and ask the new doctor the same key questions.

When it makes sense4

Set it up5

Send records4

At the visit4

From checklisted.page/checklist/getting-a-second-opinion

Send this list to someone

  1. Tap Edit to change any item so it fits you.
  2. Tap Send and share the link by text, WhatsApp or email.
  3. They tick each item on their phone, then tap Done, send it back.
  4. You open their link and see what was done, by whom and when.

No app or account. The list lives inside the link. How it works.

Common questions

Will my doctor be offended if I get a second opinion?

Most doctors are used to it and many encourage it for big decisions. You can ask them to send your records.

Does insurance pay for a second opinion?

Many plans do. Medicare Part B covers a second opinion for medically necessary surgery that is not an emergency, and a third if the first two disagree. Check your plan.

What if the two opinions differ?

Ask the doctors to explain why, ask if they can talk, or get a third opinion. Then choose the plan that fits your goals.

Learn more

Plain-English guides from our sister sites:

This list helps you remember things. It is not legal, medical, tax or financial advice. Rules differ by state, so check with the office or professional in charge. Disclaimer.